How to Find a Good Digital Marketing Agency (Without Getting Burned)
- Mahesh VR
- Jan 1
- 11 min read
Looking For A Good Digital Marketing Agency?
If you’re reading this article, chances are that you’re looking to hire a digital marketing agency, and that's great. If you want to save time and directly get in touch with us, click the button below.
Maybe you tried running ads yourself and burned ₹50,000 with nothing to show for it. Maybe your cousin's friend who "does social media" stopped replying after three weeks. Or maybe you just don't have time to figure out SEO, Google Ads, and content marketing on top of running your actual business.
So you start Googling.
And you find 200 agencies, all promising the same thing: "guaranteed results," "3x ROI in 90 days," "we'll get you 50 qualified leads this month."
Half of them have websites that look identical. The other half have portfolios showcasing clients you've never heard of. And every single one claims they're different.
You schedule a few calls. They ask surface-level questions, pitch you a standard package, and send a proposal that sounds impressive but doesn't actually explain how they'll get you results.
You pick one. Maybe because their price was lowest. Maybe because they were the most confident.
Maybe because you were tired of looking and just wanted to do something.
Three months later, you've spent ₹3 lakhs, received some reports with charts and percentages, but your actual business hasn't changed. Lead volume is the same. Revenue is flat. When you ask what's working, they send vague answers about "building momentum" and "long-term strategy."
You fire them and start the process over.
This happens to thousands of businesses every year. And it's not because good agencies don't exist, it's because most businesses don't know what to look for until after they've already wasted money.
This guide will show you how to find a marketing agency that delivers the results it promised, what red flags to watch for, and what questions to ask before signing anything.
How To Avoid Agencies That Overpromise and Underdeliver
We've worked with clients who came to us after hiring two or three agencies before us.
The pattern is always the same.
The agency promised a huge result, like 50 leads per month. They delivered 8, and half of them were unqualified or fake form submissions.
The agency promised to triple revenue in one quarter. They ran some Facebook ads, posted on Instagram a few times, and sent a report showing "engagement increased by 34%", which meant nothing for the business.
The agency claimed expertise in the client's industry. But when it came time to execute, they had no idea how the business actually worked, what messaging resonated, or where the target audience was looking for solutions.
The worst part is, we heard that these agencies looked legitimate. Professional websites. Case studies. Testimonials. Pricing that seemed reasonable.
But when it came time to execute, they either didn't have the expertise, didn't have a real team, or were just churning through clients hoping a few would stick around long enough to make the retainer worthwhile.
The two most common complaints we hear from businesses who've been burned:
1. No results. The agency did “something”, posted content, ran ads, sent reports, but nothing moved. Traffic didn't increase. Leads didn't come in. Revenue stayed flat.
2. No industry knowledge. The agency treated the client like every other business. Same strategies. Same messaging. No understanding of what actually drives decisions in that market.
If you've experienced this, you're not alone. And you can avoid it by knowing what to look for before you hire.
Red Flags That Should Make You Walk Away
Before we talk about what to look for in a good agency, let's cover what should immediately disqualify
one.
1. They Pitch You Without Asking Questions
If an agency jumps straight into "here's our package" without understanding your business, your goals, or your current situation, they're not building a strategy, they're selling a template.
Good agencies ask:
What have you tried before?
What's your current revenue and customer acquisition cost?
Who's your ideal customer?
What results would make this investment worth it?
If they don't care about the answers, they don't care about the results.
2. They Make Guarantees That Sound Too Good to Be True
"We'll get you 30 clients in 30 days with ₹25,000 ad spend."
"We'll 3x your revenue in one quarter."
"We'll get you 10,000 Instagram followers in two months."
No ethical agency can guarantee exact results because marketing involves variables outside their control, your product, your market, your competition, algorithm changes, economic conditions.
Good agencies will tell you what's realistic based on data, but they won't promise specific numbers upfront. If they do, they're either lying or desperate.
3. Their Portfolio Doesn't Match What They're Selling
Some agencies list big-name clients on their website, but when you dig deeper, their involvement was minimal, maybe they ran one campaign, or consulted for a month, or the client fired them shortly after.
Ask for specifics:
What did you do for this client?
What were the measurable results?
How long did you work with them?
If they can't give clear answers, the portfolio is inflated.
4. They're Suspiciously Cheap
If an agency charges ₹10,000 per month, ask yourself how they're delivering quality work at that price.
From our experience, agencies at that price point typically hire unpaid interns or outsource everything to freelancers.
Good agencies cost more because they have real teams, real experience, and real accountability.
If the price seems too low, there's a reason.
What to Look for in a Good Digital Marketing Agency
Now that you know what to avoid, here's what actually matters.
1. They Have Real Industry Knowledge.
Marketing tactics vary wildly depending on the industry.
What works for a SaaS company doesn't work for a manufacturing business. What works for e-commerce doesn't work for professional services.
An agency that's worked in your space understands:
Where your customers research before buying
What messaging resonates
What channels actually convert
What compliance or regulatory issues matter
When an agency says "we've done this before and it worked," ask for proof. Case studies. Client
names. Specific results.
Sometimes they might be new to the industry, in which case, you’ll need to ask for their methodology on HOW they’ll help you. If they’re new, but what they’ve done enough research and they have a fair idea how it works, it’s good to go.
2. They Ask Strategic Question.
Bad agencies ask: "What's your budget? What services do you want?"
Good agencies ask: "What's your revenue goal? What's your current customer acquisition cost? What
have you tried that didn't work? What would success look like in six months?"
If they're focused on understanding your business before pitching solutions, that's a good sign.
3. They're Transparent About What's Working and What's Not
Marketing isn't a straight line. Some tactics work immediately. Some take months. Some don't work at
all and need to be adjusted.
Good agencies tell you the truth. They don't hide behind jargon or optimistic projections. They show you the data, explain what it means, and adjust strategy based on results.
At Revenueholic, we send weekly updates and monthly reports showing exactly what's happening, what's working, what's not, and what we're changing. If something isn't delivering, we say it outright and pivot.
4. They Have Their Own Team and Execute Without Micromanagement
Some agencies are just middlemen. They take your money, outsource the work to freelancers, and spend their time managing approvals and revisions instead of actually executing.
Good agencies have internal teams or trusted partners who handle strategy and execution. They don't come to you asking what to do. They build the plan, get your input, and execute.
We onboard clients in 7-10 days and start working at full capacity without requiring clients to fill out 50-page brand questionnaires or sit through endless strategy meetings. We ask the questions that matter, do the research ourselves, and get to work.
5. They're Upfront About Pricing and What It Gets You
Good agencies explain their pricing clearly:
What's included
What's not included
How billing works
What results are realistic at different budget levels
To work with any serious agency, plan on spending at least $2,000 per month (roughly ₹1.7 lakhs). That might sound expensive, but effective marketing requires testing multiple channels, creating quality content, running ads, and optimizing based on data.
Spending less is like putting all your money into one stock and hoping it goes up. It's risky, and it rarely works.
Agencies charging ₹1 lakh+ per month have real teams, real experience, and deliver strategy + execution.
Agencies charging ₹10,000 per month are cutting corners somewhere, usually by hiring interns for free or inexperienced freelancers or delivering templated work with no customization.
6. They Say No to Bad-Fit Clients
Good agencies turn down clients who aren't a good fit.
If your expectations don't align with what they can deliver, if your budget is too low to execute properly, or if your industry is outside their expertise, they'll tell you upfront instead of taking your money and underdelivering.
At Revenueholic, we only work with industries where we've already seen success. If we don't think we can help, we say so.
7. They Focus on Outcomes, Not Deliverables
Bad agencies pitch: "We'll post 20 times per month on Instagram and send 4 email campaigns."
Good agencies pitch: "We'll increase qualified lead volume by 15% over the next 90 days by optimizing your Google Ads targeting, launching a content SEO strategy, and testing email sequences to nurture cold leads."
Clients don't care about the number of posts or emails. They care about results. Good agencies focus on the outcome and adjust tactics as needed to get there.
At Revenueholic, we don't lock ourselves into fixed deliverables. If something requires more work than
expected, we do it. If a tactic isn't working, we pivot without waiting for the next contract renewal.
If you run a business, and you're already doing well, and you want to grow it more, now might be the BEST TIME for you to get in touch with us
We'll evaluate whether we're the right fit for your business. If we're not, we'll tell you upfront. If we are, we'll show you exactly how we'll approach your growth.
What Questions to Ask Before Hiring an Agency
When you're evaluating agencies, ask these questions and pay attention to how they respond.
1. What results have you delivered for businesses like mine?
Look for specifics. Not "we've worked with e-commerce brands," but "we helped an apparel brand increase revenue by 60% in six months through a combination of Google Shopping ads and email automation."
2. What does success look like in the first 90 days?
Good agencies set realistic expectations. If they promise immediate explosive growth, be skeptical. If they explain what metrics will improve and on what timeline, that's honest.
3. How do you report results?
Ask how often they report, what metrics they track, and how they explain performance. Weekly updates? Monthly calls? Dashboard access?
If they're vague or only mention surface-level metrics like impressions, that's a red flag.
4. What happens if something isn't working?
You want to hear: "We monitor performance weekly and adjust tactics based on data. If a channel isn't converting, we reallocate budget to what's working."
If they say "just give it more time" without explaining what they'll change, they're not actually managing the campaign.
5. Who will be working on my account?
Some agencies sell you on senior leadership in the pitch meeting, then hand your account to junior staff. Ask who's doing the actual work and what their experience is.
6. What's included in your pricing, and what costs extra?
Make sure you understand what the retainer covers. Are ad budgets separate? Are design revisions unlimited or capped? What happens if you need additional services mid-contract?
How We Approach Clients Differently at Revenueholic
We've worked with clients who've been burned by agencies before. We know what doesn't work.
Fast onboarding.
We start working at full capacity within 7-10 days. No endless questionnaires. No month-long strategy phases. We ask the right questions, do the research, and execute.
Transparent reporting.
Weekly updates and monthly deep dives showing what's working, what's not, and what we're changing. No hiding behind vanity metrics.
Industry expertise.
We only work with industries where we've delivered results before. If we haven't done it successfully, we won't pretend we can.
No micromanagement required.
We own strategy and execution. You don't need to approve every post or review every ad. We handle it and keep you informed.
Honest about what's realistic.
We don't promise 3x revenue in 90 days. We show you what's achievable based on data and adjust as we learn.
We say no to bad fits.
If your budget is too low, your expectations are unrealistic, or your industry is outside our expertise, we'll tell you upfront instead of taking your money.
We're typically on the higher end of pricing because we're not delivering templated work. We're building custom strategies, executing at a high level, and staying accountable for results.
Here's an example - We helped OpenCraft AI rank #1 on Google for competitive keywords in under two weeks using next-gen SEO tactics. Read the full case study here.
The Costs of Hiring the Wrong Agency
Cheap agencies waste your money and damage your brand.
We've seen businesses hire agencies that:
Destroyed their domain authority with spammy backlinks
Tanked their ad account quality score with poorly targeted campaigns
Damaged their brand reputation with low-quality content or tone-deaf messaging
Fixing these problems costs more than hiring the right agency in the first place.
If you choose an agency based purely on price, you'll likely spend double fixing what they broke.
Common Misconceptions About Hiring Agencies
Before you start evaluating agencies, clear these misconceptions:
Misconception 1: Good agencies are cheap.
Good agencies cost what in-house teams cost, sometimes slightly less. If you want real expertise and real results, expect to pay for it.
Misconception 2: A good agency does what you tell them.
If you want someone to execute your ideas without pushback, hire a freelancer. Agencies should challenge bad ideas and recommend better approaches based on data.
Misconception 3: Revenue share deals are safer.
If an agency agrees to 100% revenue share, they're either desperate or don't believe in their own work. Good agencies charge retainers because they're confident in delivering value.
Misconception 4: You need exact ROI forecasts before starting.
No ethical agency can predict exact ROI upfront. They can show you benchmarks, explain what's realistic, and commit to transparent reporting, but anyone promising guaranteed numbers is lying.
Misconception 5: You should micromanage everything.
If you want to approve every blog post, review every ad, and dictate every decision, you'd be better off building an in-house team. Agencies work best when you trust their expertise and let them execute.
What Happens After You Hire the Right Agency
When you find the right agency, the relationship looks different.
You're not constantly chasing updates. You're not wondering if your money is being wasted. You're not micromanaging approvals.
Instead:
You get regular updates showing what's happening and why
You see measurable improvements in traffic, leads, or revenue
You have strategic conversations about growth, not tactical debates about individual posts
You trust the agency to handle execution while you focus on running your business
That's what a good partnership looks like.
The Bottom Line: Don't Settle for "Good Enough"
Hiring a digital marketing agency is a big decision.
Done right, it accelerates your growth, frees up your time, and gives you access to expertise you couldn't build in-house.
Done wrong, it wastes money, damages your brand, and sets you back months.
Don't hire based on price alone. Don't hire the first agency that sounds confident. Don't hire because you're tired of looking.
Take the time to evaluate properly. Ask hard questions. Look for red flags. Find an agency with real experience in your industry, transparent reporting, and a track record of delivering outcomes, not just deliverables.
Want to Work with a Marketing Agency That Checks All The Green Flags
If you've been burned by agencies before, we get it.
At Revenueholic, we don't overpromise. We don't hide behind reports. We don't lock you into rigid deliverables.
We build custom strategies, execute them, stay transparent about what's working, and take full accountability for results.
and we'll evaluate whether we're the right fit for your business. If we're not, we'll tell you upfront. If we are, we'll show you exactly how we'll approach your growth.
Comments